In April of 2016, Canadian family law attorney Brian Ludmer delivered a slide-based presentation and accompanying lecture to the Cleveland and Columbus Bar Associations in Ohio, where he addressed several legal, psychological, and practical challenges in legal cases involving parental alienation (PA).

Under the catch-all title Managing the Parental Alienation Case, the presentation drew on Ludmer’s decades of experience representing clients in high-conflict custody disputes. He concentrated on strategies attorneys can use to identify instances of PA, establish supporting evidence, and pursue effective legal responses.

Understanding the Complexities of Parental Alienation

One of the main themes of the session was the sheer difficulty of distinguishing PA from other explanations for a child’s rejection of a parent. Ludmer explained that the outward behaviour of children and parents doesn’t necessarily indicate the true causes of a damaged relationship. For example, a child’s refusal to spend time with one parent may be influenced by ongoing persuasion from the other parent, but it may also stem from other grievances. 

He stressed that lawyers, assessors, and mental health professionals must always carefully review the family’s history from as many viewpoints as possible before coming to any conclusions, and that this should include the conduct of both parents, as well as the events leading up to the deterioration of the relationship. 

Ludmer also addressed the importance of considering competing narratives, as parents in high-conflict custody disputes tend to offer differing accounts of past events and conversations, while children’s accounts do not always provide a complete picture of the family dynamics.

The Role of Lawyers and the Importance of Evidence

Another section of Managing the Parental Alienation Case concerned the responsibilities of legal counsel and the development of effective litigation strategies.

Here, Ludmer explained that lawyers handling PA cases ought to have something more than a simple working knowledge of family law. They must also understand certain psychological concepts, be able to recognize potential problems with assessments, and conceive legal strategies beneficial to the long-term interests of the children involved.

From there, he outlined some practical steps for building a solid case, including:

  • Preparing a detailed timeline documenting the history of the parent-child relationship and any significant events following separation.
  • Maintaining records of interactions between parents, children, and any other important parties involved in the dispute.
  • Gathering the relevant documents and testimony from independent sources.
  • Examining the methods and conclusions of custody assessors, therapists, and other expert witnesses.
  • Identifying patterns that may have contributed or still be contributing to the deterioration of family relationships.

During his presentation, Brian Ludmer also cautioned against allowing unnecessary delays in litigation, as that can cause already strained relationships to become increasingly difficult to repair.

Legal Remedies and Therapeutic Interventions

Additionally, Ludmer argued that conventional approaches to family counselling and individual therapy may prove ineffective when the underlying problem involves the broader family unit rather than the conduct or emotional well-being of an individual. Instead, he advocated for interventions that define professional responsibilities, track progress, and work alongside court orders and pre-existing parenting arrangements. 

Some responses discussed included court-ordered counselling, parental education, increased parenting time, structured reunification programs, and, in particularly serious circumstances, protective separation.

Importantly, the presentation emphasized that the appropriateness of any particular remedy depends on the evidence and circumstances of the individual case.

Working with Parents and Other Professionals

As his presentation continued, Ludmer also discussed the emotional difficulties experienced by parents who believe they have been rejected by their children without good reason. He highlighted the importance of helping those parents maintain a balanced perspective, document relevant events, and avoid any sort of conduct that could undermine their legal position. He then examined the responsibilities of the parent favoured by the child, including supporting a healthy relationship with the other parent and complying with court orders. 

Another concern was the influence of third parties, such as therapists, other lawyers, custody evaluators, and extended family members. Here, Ludmer cautioned that poorly defined professional roles, incomplete investigations, and conflicting sets of advice can serve to complicate already difficult cases.

He went on to address the subject of expert evidence, stressing the importance of verifying the qualifications of any outside professionals, as well as examining their investigative methods and any potential biases.

Protecting Children’s Long-Term Interests

Finally, Brian Ludmer discussed how prolonged family conflict can damage parent-child relationships, affect children’s independent judgment, and create feelings of divided loyalty within a family. He also examined the role of children’s stated wishes in custody disputes. He argued that while it’s important to hear children’s wishes, their views must also be considered alongside their family history and other relevant, possibly extenuating circumstances. It was in this context that he voiced a proposal for a Children’s Charter of Rights and Responsibilities, which would outline principles for protecting children’s relationships with both parents. 

Anyone curious to see the full slideshow can download a PDF of the document here.

About Brian Ludmer

With more than three decades of legal experience to his credit, Brian Ludmer is the founder and lead lawyer at the Toronto-based firm Ludmer Law. His work in complex custody disputes and parental alienation matters goes well beyond the courtroom and the negotiating table, and extends into the realms of policy discussion, media appearances, professional lectures, and national and international advocacy. A co-founder of Lawyers for Shared Parenting, Ludmer has also advised organizations such as the International Support Network for Alienated Families and the Parental Alienation Awareness Organization. He also helped to draft Bill C-560, which was a proposal to extend the assumption of equal shared parenting across Canada, and co-authored The High-Conflict Custody Battle: Protect Yourself and Your Kids from a Toxic Divorce, False Accusations, and Parental Alienation.

See Similar Blog Posts

Brian Ludmer’s Co-Authored Research on Gender, Abuse Allegations, and Parental Alienation 

A Look Back at Brian Ludmer’s 2017 PASG Presentation on the Voice of the Child in Family Law Cases

Brian Ludmer Selected to Contribute to New Book on Parental Alienation

Brian Ludmer Webinar on Proving Parental Alienation Cases Now Available Online